top of page

How to Hire for Cultural Fit Without Compromising on Skills

7 minutes

7 August 2025

Some hires look perfect on paper. Great experience, solid skills, impressive references. But two months in, something’s off. Communication feels clunky, they’re not syncing with the team, and you’re constantly second-guessing the decision.


This is called a culture misfit. And it costs more than you think – in time, morale, and team momentum.


If you’re scaling a team and want to avoid this completely avoidable mistake, you need to sharpen your skills in one area: knowing how to hire for cultural fit. In this blog, we’ll break down what culture fit actually means, why it matters, and how to evaluate it for every hire.


What Is Culture Fit, Really?


Culture fit isn’t about hiring someone who vibes with you or someone you’d grab a drink with. It’s also not about whether they like the same music, live in the same city, or share your sense of humour.


Culture fit ≠ culture clone.


When we say 'culture fit,' we mean shared values, compatible working styles, and aligned expectations. Do they thrive in fast-paced environments? Are they comfortable with feedback? Can they work with a high level of autonomy? Do they make decisions the way your team does?


That’s culture fit.


But here’s where most teams slip up. They confuse culture fit with culture add. Culture fit is about alignment. Culture add is about bringing in perspectives, experiences, and ideas that your team doesn’t currently have but still aligns with your values and ways of working.


You need both.


Why Is Cultural Fit Important When You’re Hiring?


Skills will get the job done.


Culture fit is what determines how the job gets done and whether it works for your team long-term.


When you hire for culture fit, you’re not just looking for competence. You’re looking for someone who communicates the way your team communicates, who makes decisions at the same speed, who responds to feedback the way your company gives it. That alignment removes friction. It makes working together smoother, faster, and less stressful.


Bad culture fit hires aren’t always obvious. Sometimes they just don’t click. They do the work, but it doesn’t land. They show up, but something always feels a little off.


On the flip side, when someone’s the right fit culturally, they ramp faster, ask better questions, and often go beyond what’s expected because how they work makes sense in your context. That’s not a soft win. That’s a compounding one.


How to Evaluate Cultural Fit (Without Falling Into Bias)


We are not saying that cultural fit should be a gut feeling. It’s not about whether you “clicked” in the interview or if they seemed “easy to get along with.” This is how bias creeps in, especially when hiring across geographies or backgrounds.


Consider these points when you’re evaluating culture fit:


  1. Get clear on your culture first.


You can’t assess alignment if you haven’t defined what your team values. Do you move fast? Do you give blunt feedback or wait for structured meetings? Do you work async-first? If you’re vague on what you stand for, every interview becomes a guessing game.


  1. Look for alignment in how they work, not just what they say.


Instead of asking “Do you value ownership?”, dig into examples like -


  • What’s your approach when you’re stuck and your manager is offline?

  • How do you typically prefer to receive feedback in a team setting?

  • What does autonomy at work mean to you?


You’re not just listening to the answer; you’re listening for whether their instincts and defaults match how your team runs.


  1. Don’t evaluate culture fit alone.


If you’re the founder or hiring manager, loop in others from the team. Culture shows up in different ways depending on who they’re interacting with. A candidate might vibe well with leadership but clash with peers or vice versa.


  1. Use scorecards and structure.


Have a consistent set of cultural criteria for each role. Add notes. Use ratings. It’s not about making hiring robotic but making it fair and consistent.


  1. Trial tasks or shadowing will tell you more than interviews ever will.


Especially in remote roles. A short async task, a 2-day shadow sprint, or a paid trial week can show you how they collaborate, how they ask for help, and how they deliver. All of that gives you a better signal than any well-rehearsed answer.


The point is you’re not trying to figure out if someone’s “nice” or “a good person.” You’re trying to understand if this person will thrive in the way your team works without you having to constantly translate, nudge, or clean up after.


That’s what good cultural evaluation looks like.


💡 Bonus: Try out these free virtual team-building activities. (They’re fun - we promise!)


Common Mistakes Teams Make When Hiring for Culture Fit


Even teams that care about culture fit often get it wrong, and not because they’re careless. It’s usually because they’re moving fast, relying too much on instinct, or haven’t taken the time to define what “fit” really means for them.


Here are the common traps we see:


  • Hiring based on “vibes.”

Culture fit isn’t about whether someone feels easy to talk to. That usually just signals familiarity, not alignment. When you hire based on who feels familiar, you risk building a team that looks, thinks, and works exactly like you, which leads to limited diversity, creativity, and resilience.


  • Mistaking culture fit for personality match.

Introverts can be culture fits. So can direct communicators, quiet builders, or people who don’t make small talk. Don’t filter people out because they’re not “fun” or “chatty.” Culture fit is about how they work, not how they socialise.


  • Not documenting your culture.

If your company values and working principles live only in your head, you’re going to make inconsistent hiring decisions. Write them down. Share them in your JD. Use them as a filter in interviews. If you don’t name your culture, it will default to whatever the loudest people decide it is.


  • Over-prioritising culture fit and ignoring skill gaps.

Yes, culture fit matters, but if someone doesn’t have the capability to do the work, alignment won’t make up for it. You need both. Don’t lower the bar on skill just because the person feels easy to work with.


  • Leaving culture fit evaluation to chance.

Some teams assume “we’ll get a sense in the interview.” You won’t unless you build specific signals and questions into your process. Culture fit needs to be tested and observed, not assumed.


The good news? All of these are fixable. You just need a bit of structure and a strong internal compass.


Hiring for Culture Fit in Remote Teams 


We run a fully remote team ourselves and work with other remote teams every day, so we know firsthand how tricky culture fit can get when you’re not in the same room. You can’t rely on casual interactions, body language, or “office vibe” to fill in the blanks. Everything needs to be more intentional.


Here’s what changes when you hire for culture fit remotely:


Async vs sync preferences matter. 

If your team works async and a candidate needs real-time collaboration to move forward, that’s a mismatch. It’s not personal, it’s just incompatible. Culture fit here means shared rhythm, not shared hours.


Communication becomes the culture.

Without casual in-office interactions, the way someone writes, responds, and follows up is your window into how they operate. You’ll want people who default to clarity, initiative, and documentation. Those aren’t just skills, they’re cultural traits in remote teams.


Trial tasks and written exercises give a better signal.

You can’t rely on in-person energy or body language to gauge fit. Instead, test them in the environment they’ll actually work in. A short async project, a Loom walkthrough, a Slack-based discussion; these will show you exactly how they operate.


Timezone overlap isn’t everything, but working style is.

You don’t need full overlap across continents. But you do need shared expectations on turnaround times, availability, and responsiveness. That’s where culture fit lives in remote teams.


Trust and accountability become non-negotiable.

When you’re not in the same office, micromanagement won’t work. People need to take ownership, push updates, and escalate blockers without being asked. If that’s how your team works, hire for it intentionally.


Wrapping Up


To wrap this up, hiring for culture fit is hiring someone who gets how your team works, how you communicate, move, make decisions, and navigate challenges.


And when you get it right, everything gets easier. People ramp faster. Feedback lands better. Work flows smoothly. You don’t spend your energy managing mismatches; you spend it building.


So here’s the short version of how to hire for cultural fit: Define your culture. Build structure into your process. And don’t rely on your gut.


We excel in this area at GrowthBuddy. We don’t just screen for skills. We shortlist candidates who work like you do. Culture fit isn’t a checkbox for us; it’s the baseline. If you’ve been burned by hires that looked good on paper but didn’t quite click, let us help you fix that.


bottom of page